Musings of a fickle mind

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

American Idol Season 9 Review #9 Top 10

I'll just keep this short...I'll name the good, the just ok, and the bad & bland. Here we go:

Good:

Lee Dewyze (Favorite moment!!!)
Crystal Bowersox (Apparently really like her even without the guitar!)
Katie Stevens (Her voice is gorgeous here!!! lol..absolutely in her element)
Mike Lynche (Don't like him..but this is another solid performance from him)

OK:

Casey James (Was ok, but nothing special...he's starting to sound the same; want him to go back to "Heaven" mode)
Andrew Garcia (He stepped it up this week big time..not sure if this secures a long term position for him in the competition though...he's made a fair share of clumsy decisions resulting in a lot of bad weeks for him)
Didi Benami (She's sooo emotional!! This performance was old-fashioned and boring..but i do love the tone of her voice. She has to go back to the singer-songwriter vibe that she had in the past)
Aaron Kelly (This song has been sung magnificently by past idols...Aaron's unfortunately paled in comparison. is it just me or does it seem he did WAAAAY better with in the pre-performance footage with Usher??

Bad and Bland

Siobhan Magnus (I really hate to put Siobhan here...but this performance was over the place!! I think it would've been better if the key was lower or something...no doubt she could hit the notes, but sometimes she has the tendency to sound screechy and fall off key ...she however is entitled to a bad week as Kara had mentioned..she's been quite consistent) SAVE SIOBHAN!!!!

Time Urban (Nothing more to say.the song choice was just plain weird....he seemed a bit likable though with his positive attitude and everything...think that he's leaving this week..at least he got to make it to the tour)

BOTTOM 3 prediction: Tim Urban, Andrew Garcia, Didi Benami (Siobhan and Aaron may be in danger as well though :( )

No comments:

Post a Comment